Dietary Tannins in Cultured Fish: Growth Promoter or Metabolic Burden? A Meta-Analysis

Authors: Prakoso, Vitas Atmadi; Adli, Danung Nur; Sholikin, Mohammad Miftakhus; Lusiana, Evellin Dewi; Ginanjar, Rendy; Ariyanti, Dita; Wardani, Wira Wisnu; Hafizuddin, Hafizuddin; Rasidi, Rasidi; Afandi, Frendy Ahmad; Wardiny, Tuty Maria; Saleh, Muhammad Ismunandar Yasin; Iswantari, Aliati; Kurniawan, Kurniawan; Doyle, Katherine E; Wibowo, Arif; Jayanegara, Anuraga

Source journal: Aquaculture nutrition (2026-01-01)

DOI: 10.1155/anu/2460161

Abstract

Tannins are being increasingly explored as functional feed additives in aquaculture; however, their effects remain context-dependent. This meta-analysis assessed the impact of dietary tannin supplementation on growth, nutrient digestibility, physiological stress, immunity and gut morphology in cultured fish. A total of 97 studies were included, and standardised mean differences (Hedges' g) were calculated for various growth performance and health parameters. Subgroup analyses were conducted according to tannin category, trophic guild, habitat and fish species. In general, tannin supplementation negatively affected several aspects of growth and nutrient utilisation, including feed consumption, protein utilisation, nutrient digestibility, digestive enzyme activity and lipid deposition, together with poorer feed efficiency as reflected by increased feed conversion ratio (FCR) in several major sub-groups. The negative impacts of tannins were more pronounced for fish cultured in freshwater and those classified as either omnivores or herbivores, while there was less consistency in the degree to which growth reduction was produced by tannins among carnivorous species. Dose-response analysis identified significant relationships for several key outcomes, although tannin inclusion level explained only a modest proportion of the observed variation, and no general optimum inclusion level was identified for growth responses. However, even though there was little evidence to suggest that survival was negatively impacted, this suggests that tannins acted primarily as sub-lethal nutritional stressors rather than acute toxicants. While levels of certain antioxidants and markers of immune function tended to increase in several sub-groups, the magnitude of such increases should be viewed cautiously, since they occurred alongside impaired growth and nutrient utilisation. Therefore, tannins should not be recommended using a simple inclusion-level threshold; their application in aquafeeds should be evaluated according to tannin category, botanical source, analysed tannin concentration, fish species, feeding guild, habitat, basal diet composition and digestibility responses.

Read the full text

Related topics

Related open access articles

Abstract and bibliographic data from PubMed (U.S. National Library of Medicine). Copyright of the abstract belongs to the original publisher or authors.