Environmental contamination, human rights and medico-legal responsibility after Cannavacciuolo and Others v Italy (ECtHR)

Authors: Cioffi, Andrea; Cipolloni, Luigi; Cecannecchia, Camilla

Source journal: The Medico-legal journal (2026-11-17)

DOI: 10.1177/00258172261479869

Abstract

Environmental contamination is increasingly recognised as a human rights issue engaging State obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). In Cannavacciuolo and Others v Italy, the European Court of Human Rights held that prolonged environmental exposure may trigger positive obligations under Article 2 ECHR, requiring public authorities to identify, monitor and mitigate foreseeable risks to life. Implementing these obligations depends on the integration of environmental, clinical and epidemiological evidence. This paper argues that legal medicine can provide the methodological bridge between legal principles and scientific assessment. We propose an Integrated Environmental Medico-Legal Assessment Framework (I-EMAF), a conceptual model supporting transparent, multidisciplinary and evidence-based evaluation of environmental contamination. Rather than introducing new investigative methods, I-EMAF organises established scientific approaches within a coherent medico-legal structure to assist courts, public authorities and healthcare systems to implement their Article 2 obligations.

Read the full text

Related topics

Related open access articles

Abstract and bibliographic data from PubMed (U.S. National Library of Medicine). Copyright of the abstract belongs to the original publisher or authors.