Lead contamination near operating primary smelters: 40 years of Port Pirie data reveal the limits of receptor-side management

Authors: Miller, Graeme D K; Johnston, Scott G; Karimian, Niloofar; Burton, Edward D

Source journal: Environmental geochemistry and health (2026-11-20)

DOI: 10.1007/s10653-026-03614-w

Abstract

Primary smelters release lead (Pb) emissions that can drive harmful childhood exposure. Receptor-side management, including community education, household decontamination, soil remediation and blood-Pb surveillance, is widely used to mitigate such exposure. This review critically synthesises more than 40 years of multi-media Pb data from Port Pirie (South Australia), and compares it with data from other smelter communities, to test whether receptor-side management successfully holds blood-Pb at contemporary health-based levels while smelter emissions continue. Port Pirie is home to one of the world's largest primary Pb-Zn smelters, an adjacent population of about 14,000, and a receptor-side program that began in 1984. Smelter emissions have continually reloaded the city's air, dust, soil and other environmental reservoirs with highly bioavailable Pb. Childhood blood-Pb in Port Pirie fell from extreme early-1980s levels, but the decline stalled toward the mid-2010s. From 2014 to 2025, the percentage of tested 2-year-olds with blood-Pb > 5 microg dL(-)(1) rose from 49.6 to 79.8%, while stack air-Pb emissions increased almost fourfold (with available evidence suggesting that total reported air-Pb emissions may now be of a similar order of magnitude to those reported in the early 1980s). Comparison with other smelter communities, including source-reduced operations at Trail (British Columbia, Canada) and Hoboken (Antwerp, Belgium) and closure cases at Bunker Hill (Idaho, USA), Herculaneum (Missouri, USA) and Boolaroo (New South Wales, Australia), shows that blood-Pb drops to contemporary health-based levels only after substantial cuts in source flux or smelter closure, not from receptor-side measures alone. The evidence assembled in this review suggests that receptor-side management alone is unlikely to consistently achieve contemporary childhood blood-Pb targets where substantial ongoing smelter emissions persist.

Read the full text

Related topics

Related open access articles

Abstract and bibliographic data from PubMed (U.S. National Library of Medicine). Copyright of the abstract belongs to the original publisher or authors.