Operational criteria for the ethical justification of wastewater surveillance

Authors: Sun, Yimei; Pang, Junxiong Vincent; Wulandari, Suci Melati; Liu, Elyssa; Hipgrave, David B; Oktaria, Vicka; Amir, Afreenish; Nisar, Imran; Karlsson, Erik A; Pronyk, Paul Michael

Source journal: BMC global and public health (2026-11-20)

DOI: 10.1186/s44263-026-00342-2

Abstract

Wastewater surveillance (WWS) for pathogen monitoring is transitioning from emergency deployment to routine monitoring of endemic pathogens, yet ethical guidance has not kept pace. As implementation becomes more granular and supported by advanced next-generation sequencing, neither blanket consent waivers nor opt-in/opt-out models can adequately address the complex ethical risks inherent in WWS. Drawing on ethical, legal and scientific expertise, this Perspective article operationalizes five justificatory conditions drawn from public health ethics, namely public justification, effectiveness, proportionality, necessity, and least infringement, for WWS contexts in which individual consent is infeasible. It translates these conditions into scenario-based evaluation criteria and procedures, requiring meaningful public engagement and treating non-deployment as a legitimate option where WWS cannot be sufficiently justified, alongside safeguards such as limited data retention and host-DNA depletion. This Perspective article therefore provides one step towards bridging the gap between high-level guidelines and field implementation, supporting accountable practice and sustained public trust.

Read the full text

Related topics

Related open access articles

Abstract and bibliographic data from PubMed (U.S. National Library of Medicine). Copyright of the abstract belongs to the original publisher or authors.