Quantifying biodiversity and ecosystem service trade-offs to inform forest landscape management under changing conditions

Authors: Sedmak, Robert; Brodrechtova, Yvonne; BahyI, Jan; Tucek, Jan

Source journal: PloS one (2026-01-01)

DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0359884

Abstract

Forested landscapes provide a wide range of ecosystem services (ES) and support biodiversity, yet both are increasingly threatened by intensive management practices and climate change. Understanding trade-offs and synergies between biodiversity and multiple ES is essential for identifying sustainable forest management strategies. In this study, we quantified long-term interactions between biodiversity and selected ES at the landscape scale under changing management behavior and climate-related conditions. We applied a multicriteria optimization framework combined with long-term forest growth simulations to a large temperate mountain region in Central Europe. Biodiversity and ecosystem service indicators were derived from an empirical forest growth simulator and evaluated under 1,980 combinations of ownership structure, management approaches, disturbance intensity, vegetation shifts, and species composition changes over a 120-year period. Trade-offs and synergies were analyzed using Pareto frontiers and visualized through multidimensional decision maps. The results showed that variability in biodiversity and ecosystem service provision was explained primarily by forest structure and historical forest management legacies, particularly age-class distribution and forest management zoning. In contrast, simulated future changes in management behavior or climate change-related disturbances contributed only marginally to overall variability within the analyzed time horizon. Clear trade-offs were identified between biodiversity and wood production, as well as between biodiversity and soil and water regulation and recreation, largely driven by the structural constraints of even-aged forest systems. Opportunities for simultaneous improvement of multiple ES and biodiversity were limited and occurred mainly in suboptimal system states. Our findings indicate that forest landscape multifunctionality is strongly constrained by long-term structural legacies. Meaningful improvements in biodiversity and ecosystem service provision at the landscape scale therefore require long-term, structural management strategies rather than short-term optimization of individual services.

Read the full text

Related topics

Related open access articles

Abstract and bibliographic data from PubMed (U.S. National Library of Medicine). Copyright of the abstract belongs to the original publisher or authors.