What counts as evidence: the dangers of dismissing journalism as a Knowledge in evidence synthesis
Authors: Haddaway, Neal R; Grainger, Matthew
Source journal: Environmental evidence (2026-11-16)
DOI: 10.1186/s13750-026-00395-8
Abstract
This article critiques the persistent marginalisation of investigative journalism as an alternative Knowledge relative to scientific research, particularly in the context of rigorous evidence synthesis. While systematic reviewing and mapping methodologies have evolved over more than three decades to influence decision-making, we argue that an implicit, "false" hierarchy continues to dismiss non-academic Knowledges. We exemplify this bias through our experience of editorial pushback during the peer-review of an overview on salmon aquaculture, where citations of investigative journalism used for contextualising knowledge gaps were questioned for their robustness. We contend that investigative journalism should be recognised as a rigorous, independent form of Knowledge that parallels academic synthesis through structured hypothesis formation, data collection, and meticulous legal verification. Unlike traditional scientific research, which may be hampered by slow funding cycles or industry influence, investigative journalism provides a proactive and timely means of holding power to account. This is demonstrated through a case study of a DeSmog investigation into aquacultural supply chains, which revealed links between certified European fish farms and unsustainable Senegalese fisheries-a finding not easily captured by traditional hypothesis testing. We conclude by rejecting the notion that citing such reports indicates a lack of reflexivity or academic rigour. Instead, we call upon the scientific community and journal editors to broaden their definitions of admissible Knowledge. By integrating investigative journalism into the background and discussion of scientific outputs, researchers can better address knowledge gaps, enhance stakeholder trust, and prevent the damaging effects of siloed academic thinking on real-world decision-making.
Related topics
Related open access articles
- Towards diversification of aquaculture in Ghana: Reproductive response of Sarotherodon melanotheron to locally formulated fish feed
- Consumers Demands on Organic Aquaculture Product in Bangladesh: A review from an Emerging Market perspective
- Practical and essential information on water reuse systems in experimental aquaculture production: a descriptive review
- Impacts of probiotics on feeding technology and its application in aquaculture
- Modeling of energy intensity in aquaculture: Future energy use of global aquaculture
- Determination of an optimal daily dietary ration for large two-year-old mulloway (Argyrosomus japonicus) using current commercial feed management practices.
Abstract and bibliographic data from PubMed (U.S. National Library of Medicine). Copyright of the abstract belongs to the original publisher or authors.